The 1994 Killer is the main antagonist or secondary antagonist in Season 3. This killer has managed to keep themselves a secret for 20 years.

The identity of the Killer is rumored, which will be revealed in Season 3. Brandon James was accused of being the murderer due to his mask being the main face of the spree.

Piper Shaw and Kieran Wilcox brought back the legacy of 1994 on September 28, 2015; the first murders of the present day. The first victims were Nina Patterson and Tyler O'Neill.