Key
| Colour | Character Status |
|---|---|
| Continues | Alive and wasn't attacked |
| Absent | Doesn't appear |
| Attacked | Attacked and survives |
| Dies | Killed |
| Vision | Hallucination or vision |
| Voice | Heard, but not seen |
| Flashback | Flashback |
| Corpse | Seen as corpse |
| Killer | Killer |
| Killer | Killer, and is killed |
| # | Character | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| Survived | Emma Duval | Continues | Attacked | Continues | Attacked | ||||||
| Survived | Audrey Jensen | Continues | Attacked | ||||||||
| Survived | Noah Foster | Continues | Attacked | Continues | |||||||
| Survived | Brooke Maddox | Continues | Attacked | Continues | Attacked | ||||||
| Survived | Maggie Duval | Continues | Attacked | ||||||||
| Survived | Jake Fitzgerald | Continues | Attacked | Continues | |||||||
| Survived | Kieran Wilcox | Continues | Absent | Continues | |||||||
| Survived | Seth Branson | Continues | Absent | Continues | Absent | Continues | |||||
| Survived | Quinn Maddox | Absent | Continues | Absent | Continues | Absent | |||||
| Survived | Lorraine Brock | Absent | Continues | Absent | |||||||
| Survived | Kevin Duval | Absent | Voice | Hallucination | Absent | ||||||
| 10 | Piper Shaw | Absent | Continues | Killer | |||||||
| 9 | Sheriff Hudson | Continues | Attacked | Dies | |||||||
| 8 | Deputy Clifton Roberts | Dies | Corpse | ||||||||
| 7 | Will Belmont | Continues | Attacked | Dies | Hallucination | ||||||
| 6 | Riley Marra | Continues | Dies | ||||||||
| 5 | Brett Keener | Dies | |||||||||
| 4 | Dara Aldean | Dies | |||||||||
| 3 | Rachel Murray | Continues | Dies | Voice | |||||||
| 2 | Nina Patterson | Dies | Corpse | Flashback | |||||||
| 1 | Tyler O'Neill | Dies | Corpse | ||||||||
Victims
Season 1
| No. | Image | Name | Cause of Death | Episode Death | Killed By |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  | Tyler O'Neill | Decapitated (off-screen) | Pilot | Piper Shaw |
| 2 |  | Nina Patterson | Throat Slit | Pilot | Piper Shaw |
| 3 |  | Rachel Murray | Hung/Neck snapped in rope noose | Hello, Emma | Kieran Wilcox |
| 4 |  | Riley Marra | Stabbed in back twice, Femoral artery slashed | Wanna Play A Game? | Piper Shaw |
| 5 |  | Will Belmont | Head Sliced in Half by a Trencher | In The Trenches | Piper Shaw |
| 6 |  | Deputy Clifton Roberts | Stabbed to death with a rescue knife | The Dance | Piper Shaw |
| 7 |  | Sheriff Clark Hudson | Disemboweled (indirectly off-screen) | Revelations | Kieran Wilcox |
| 8 |  | Grayson Pfeiffer | Throat Slit (off-screen) | Revelation | Piper Shaw |
| 9 |  | Piper Shaw | Shot | Revelation | Emma Duval |
